In John Steinbeck's Of Mice and Men, who actually steals Carlson's gun? . The fate of Candys ancient dog, which Carlson shoots in the back of the head in an alleged act of mercy, foreshadows the manner of Lennies death. Candy also had a close relationship with his dog. The next day he has no dog, and when the other guys go out to the field he has nobody to comfort him. Latest answer posted December 31, 2020 at 3:22:45 PM. Curley is beating Lennie up and Lennie is not protecting himself. Candy's dog ran away and was never seen again. Discount, Discount Code As the men marvel over it, Carlson offers to kill the dog quickly by shooting it in the back of the head. Later, in chapter three, Carlson gives two more reasons why the dog should be put down. Why does Candy say that he should have shot his dog himself instead of letting a stranger do it? How does that seem, given, The dog ( represents George and Lennie's friendship ) is all that he has and grew up with. Was Carlson killing Candys dog justified? At the same time, the concept of shooting something to save it from a miserable life foreshadows the tragic events that will unfold between George and Lennie at the end of the story. Candy virtually has no choice but to let the dog go because he would be shunned by the men and Carlson would continue to badger him, and then probably act on his own, anyway. While this may have been true, it was clearly not the whole story. He probably owns the Luger because he served in World War I and either took it from a captured German officer or bought it from another soldier. She loved that dog more than anything and couldn't believe that Carlson would do something like that. Before George meets Lennie in the woods in the final scene, whose gun does he take. How is Lennie different from the other men? The guys leaves him back at the ranch while they go to drink and sleep with women. His hand is cut off, so he can't lift stuff. What does the shooting of Candys dog foreshadow? Later regretting his decision, Candy wishes he would have done it himself. First, as he says, the dog is clearly in pain and suffering. At the end of the novel, George kills Lennie in much the same way as Carlson kills Candys dog. He wants to put the dog out of its missery.Candy didnt want him to do that becase hes been with this dog forever. This causes Candy to become even more lonely and isolated. The book is written in such a way that it could obviously be adapted into a script with a minimum of time and trouble. However, much like Candys old dog, once ranch workers could not work, they would lose their ability to provide for themselves or have a purpose in life, being quickly replaced by younger, more physically able workers. Candy's dog was a very active and friendly dog. He has nothing to look forward to and nothing in his life, this dream gives him something to live for and look forward to, Spanish 2 Vocabulary Quiz 8 PS on Las Fiestas, Spanish 2 Vocabulary Quiz 9 PS on Las Celebra, A Tale of Two Cities: Book 2 Study Questions, The tale of two cities book 1 and beg of 2, PFL Unit 2B Summative Assessment Study Guide, PFL Unit 2 Summative Assessment Study Guide, SpringBoard English Language Arts: Grade 10, myPerspectives: English Language Arts, Grade 7, Vocabulary for Achievement: Fourth Course, myPerspectives: Grade 10, Volume 2 California Edition, Social processes, Attitudes and Behavior, Cul. Related Read: Does lazy dog have a dog menu? Free trial is available to new customers only. The bus driver lies to George and Lennie. He wont know what hit him. Trace the parallels between the relationships of Candy and his dog and George and Lennie. If George tried, for example, to hit him with a club, he might fail to knock him out, and Lennie might kill George instead. "You ******** punk," he said. What changes might an older person experience that would affect his or her clothing needs? Candy says, I dont mind takin care of him. (45)., Soon after they arrive at the ranch, George and Lennie meet some new and delightful people that they will be living with, until they earn enough money to buy a place of their own. $24.99 If he shots the dog at this place, he tells Candy that the dog won't feel anything.. At last Candy said softly and hopelessly, "Awright--take'im.". Candy was clearly attached to his dog and was devastated by its death. He aint no good to you, Candy. The "shotgun ending" of the story brings it to a conclusion; otherwise a story about the hard lives of farm workers could go on indefinitely. Why did he stop? It's also possible that Carlson was simply acting out of self-defense after the dog charged at him. George decides to be the one to kill Lennie because he didnt want Lennie to suffer at the hands of Curley. Marie et Philippe /// travailler /// centre commercial. Got no teeth, damn near blind, cant eat.[]. Carlson eventually takes the dog out of the room and shoots it; Candy does not try to stop him, he just sits there looking up at the ceiling, he doesn't do anything, because slim agrees with Carlson that he should shoot it and Slim agreed to give Candy one of his puppies. Renew your subscription to regain access to all of our exclusive, ad-free study tools. It is not clear what happened to the dog after he was shot. How do the descriptions of Curley change throughout the fight? As Carlson describes Candys dog as so God damn old he cant hardly walk and that he [s]tinks like hell, too, Carlson is trying to convince Slim to agree with him and persuade Candy to shoot his old dog. Through this description, Candys dog symbolizes how old age and decline are viewed by the ranch workers of this time period. Everybody thinks it was Lennie who stole the Luger after he killed Curley's wife and fled from the ranch. Here, Candys dog once again symbolizes the fear and realities of an aging farm worker. On page 44, the men are discussing Candys dog in the bunkhouse. George describes to Lennie the sights, sounds, and smells of the farm they hope to someday own and the description interests Candy. Candy's dog was shot by Carlson after he chased a rabbit onto Carlson's property. Our summaries and analyses are written by experts, and your questions are answered by real teachers. It's impossible to know for sure what Carlson's motivations were, but one thing is certain: his actions had a profound effect on Candy. Already a member? But this friendship didn't last because Carlson continuously complained about the odor produced by the dog. Contact us She does not like Curley, he cannot trust her, and she is not loyal. Whatever Carlson's reasons for shooting Candy's dog, it is clear that he did it with the best of intentions. I'll break their ******** necks. Carlson gives three of main reasons for wanting Candy's dog shot. Why does my dog cry when he sees other dogs? You can view our. The silence came into the room. Why is the killing of Candys dog a significant incident in the novel. It would have to be a handgun because a rifle would be too conspicuous, both when he stole it and when he used it on Lennie. Candy and his dog seem to be extensions of one another, each moving slowly and with obvious handicaps that affect their usefulness and well-being. What are Carlsons reasons for shooting Candys dog quizlet? The dog and its weakness is a symbolism Steinbeck used to compare to Candy and his missing hand. What does Lennie say, specifically, that shows this violence? Reluctantly, Candy gives in. Candy loves his old companion and can't bear the thought of killing him, but Slim, surprisingly, sides with Carlson: he'd want to be shot if he were old and crippled. Here, Candy desperately tries to hold on to his old dog and escape Carlsons pressure to shoot him because he aint no good to himself. Candy explains his history with his dog, how he had him since he was a pup, and how he was the best damn sheep dog. Through Candys pleas, his dog symbolizes a connection to the past and the common desire to hold onto the best of the past. Why does Carlson want to shoot Candy's dog? For the next 7 days, you'll have access to awesome PLUS stuff like AP English test prep, No Fear Shakespeare translations and audio, a note-taking tool, personalized dashboard, & much more! Carlson believes the dog is too old and decrepit to be of any use. to start your free trial of SparkNotes Plus. While Carlson is speaking to Slim (in chapter two of John Steinbeck's Of Mice and Men), he states the many reasons that Candy's dog needs to be put down. "What you want me to read that for?" If George had not killed Lennie, he knew someone else would in a more painful way. We can not guarantee its completeness or reliability so please use caution. You gotta get him out. In the novella, Candy tells George that Slim gave him permission to put the old dog out of its misery. Ultimately, Candy has littlechoice but to free the dog because Carlson is continuing to aggressively push him and there is potential for further harm. Why does Curley wear a glove on one hand? They care about others, and they are not willing to just stand by and watch as an innocent animal is killed. This shows how Candy is isolated due to his disability. In John Steinbeck's Of Mice and Men, who actually steals Carlson's gun? 60). Like Candys dog, Lennie depends on George to take care of him and show him what to do. How Did Critics React to Of Mice and Men? "That stink hangs around even after he's gone." Latest answer posted December 07, 2020 at 5:10:16 PM. This factor challenged Candy to fit in with the other men. Please wait while we process your payment. Carlson shot Candys dog to put it out of its misery because Candy couldnt bring himself to do it. Because it stinks and it is in pain, old, miserable ( crippled ), What are Candy's reasons for not wanting to shoot the dog? The main reason why Carlson's killing of Candy's dog was justified is because the old dog was well past its years and of no use to anyone. Which of the following characters check the dead body for vital signs? What is Carlsons solution to the problem of the dog? The combining of a word root and the combining vowel is called a(n) ___. Later, in chapter three, Carlson gives two more reasons why the dog should be put down. That dog of Candys is so God damn old he cant hardly walk. Slim asks Carlson to take a shovel with him when he goes to shoot Candy's dog because he was being careful and understanding towards Candy's dog's death. You can view our. Carlson believes the dog is too old and decrepit to be of any use Whit enters the bunkhouse with a magazine featuring a man he used to work with. Log in here. How does Lennie respond? "You can have a pup if you want to.". Steinbeck must have invented the character of Carlson primarily to establish the existence of a suitable weapon, a German Luger, which is a very distinctive-looking automatic pistol. She had raised him from a pup and he was her best friend. When Slim offers Candy a puppy and says of the old dog, That dog aint no good to himself. Related Read: Why is my dog eating frozen dog poop? Why is the man in the magazine? In the end, Candy is isolated due to his age and disability., An aging ranch handyman, Candy lost his hand in an accident and worries about his future on the ranch. She was angry at the person who shot him and felt like she needed to take revenge. Related Read: Why do dogs lay down when they see another dog? But the real reason is that Steinbeck needed to show the gun to George and to let him see how it worked and hear where to point it. Though the pet was once the best damn sheep dog as Candy states, it was put out once it stopped being productive. For example, there is hardly any prose exposition in the book. Slim sees Lennie as the best worker he has ever had. Candy had with his dog and the one George has with Lennie. The exact reason is never mentioned. They'll can me purty soon. After Carlson shot her dog, Candy was understandably upset. 2023 eNotes.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved. The weapon George uses to kill Lennie had to be a pistol because George had to keep it concealed. Already a member? He wrote a letter to the editor, praising the publication. And the silence lasted." (pg.48) Why does the image of silence play an important role at this point in the novel? Contact us Additionally, Carlson may have been worried about the dog being a burden on Candy. I never been mad, an' I ain't now. what happen that made george stop playing tricks on lennie? I don't care if you're the best welter in the country. John Steinbeck and Of Mice and Men Background. We're sorry, SparkNotes Plus isn't available in your country. In "Of Mice and Men", Carlson shoots Candy's old, disabled dog because he believes that it is the humane thing to do. He is an old man that is missing a hand. Candy is introduced in the start of chapter two, he is described indirectly by the narrator as a Stoop shouldered old man(Steinbeck 18). Why does Lennie have a dead mouse in his pocket? Carlson. Candy replies that he has had the dog for too many years to kill it, but Carlson continues to pressure him. He walked over with his heavy-legged stride and looked down at the dog. What do we learn about Curley's relationship with his wife, based on this event? on 50-99 accounts. eNotes Editorial, 15 Oct. 2014, https://www.enotes.com/homework-help/why-does-candy-agree-to-let-carlson-shoot-his-dog-471727. Fifth, the dog can no longer eat solid food; Candy gives the dog milk. Slim throwed a scare into you. 20% Latest answer posted August 09, 2017 at 8:49:59 AM. How are Lennie's actions similar to the events that happened earlier when Lennie and George were. What do we learn about the interdependence of George and Lennie? Your group members can use the joining link below to redeem their group membership. At the same time, the concept of shooting something to save it from a miserable life foreshadows the tragic events that will unfold between George and Lennie at the end of the story. In the first chapter of Of Mice and Men, what does George say to Lennie about how his life could be better without him? That dog ain't no good to himself. It ends right on the spot where George pulled the trigger. $18.74/subscription + tax, Save 25%